fbpx

Articles

From Frugal to Fancy to Buying a Peloton

By Jimmy Turner, MD
The Physician Philosopher

I’ve spent a lot of time over the last 3 and a half years teaching other people how to start and stay frugal. As a result, it became tough to loosen the purse strings for my family even after we were having substantial financial success. Is it ever okay to spend more of the money you are making? Or are we required to simply squirrel away any extra dollar that we earn? I’ve been learning that going from frugal to fancy can be tough once you’ve built those strong frugality muscles that allowed you to say no to the many things you didn’t need in order to achieve financial independence and avoid trapping yourself in your lifestyle.

How to Become Wealthy

Becoming wealthy and financially independent involves a pretty simple equation. There are only four steps, particularly while in training and for the first few years thereafter.

  1. Earn a good paycheck.
  2. Spend substantially less than you earn.
  3. Save the difference (at least 20-30%).
  4. Put that extra money towards building wealth. (i.e. pay off your debt and invest the money you’ve saved so that your money starts to work for you).

While this is a simple formula, it isn’t easy to accomplish.

The reason this simple equation is difficult to enact is that financial success is 90% behavioral finance and only 10% knowledge-based. Knowing what to do is not enough. You have to follow through with discipline and – since we are all prone to behavioral finance mistakes – get out of our own way. That’s the hard part.

Yet, once you figure all of this out, there is actually a 5th step in the equation, that is much more enjoyable:

5. Once you are achieving your financial goals, enjoy the rest!

Spend Lavishly On The Things You Love

After you are meeting all of your financial goals, I believe that you should spend lavishly on what you love. It is okay to go from frugal to fancy.

Now, don’t put words in my mouth. You still need to pay your future self first, make sure you are saving enough each year, and that your debt is paid off.

If you are in the beginning stages of accumulating wealth after training, use The 10% Rule to limit your lifestyle creep. Enjoy 10% of any increase in pay – including the difference between your last paycheck in training and first paycheck as an attending each month – and spend it on whatever your heart desires. Then, use the other 90% goes to pay off your refinanced student loans or towards your annual savings goals.

Further Reading: If you aren’t pursuing PSLF, then you should refinance your student loans. Come find out how to put as much as $750 straight into your pocket when you refinance student loans through The Physician Philosopher.

We used The 10% Rule to increase our net worth by ~$500,000 in a little more than 2 years after training. Much of that involved paying off our $200,000 in student loans, $75,000 in car payments, and some other minor debts.

Once all of that debt was gone, we noticed that we had substantially more cash flow at hand. We began to ask what we should be doing with all of this extra money? I guess that’s why they say “Cash flow is king!”

When The 10% Rule Becomes The 20% Rule (or More)

Personal finance is personal.

For us, financial freedom means becoming financially independent in our mid-40s. We don’t have any desire to limit our lifestyle further to achieve financial independence at age 40 instead of 47. It just isn’t worth it to live like paupers. Instead, we would like to enjoy today AND become financially independent early in our lives.

When I looked at our annual savings rate, which is north of $115,000 each year, I realized that we were going to achieve our FI number by our mid-40s even with conservative estimates. And those numbers didn’t include any additional income I am bringing in from The Physician Philosopher.

So, this Christmas we let the purse strings loose in a way that my wife and I have never experienced in our 10 years of marriage. When deciding what to spend this money on, we decided to spend it on our family’s health.

This included a top-of-the-line rectangular trampoline for the kids (yes we are crazy; yes it has a sturdy enclosure; yes the kids have specific rules to limit injuries). They love it and have spent hours jumping on it already. It’s good to see them get outside and get some exercise.

Even after those purchases, we had money left over in the budget that my wife and I created. In fact, we had so much left that my wife and I decided to join the Peloton Cult Club. Our bike arrives a couple days after this post goes live.

The best part about it all was that there was zero guilt and zero financial stress. We had more than enough left over even after our spending spree was done.

When Is It Okay to Spend More?

In order to not derail this personal finance blog that has been built on frugality and strong financial discipline, I thought I’d outline the things that I recommend you take care of prior to going from frugal to fancy in your household, too!

#1 Make Your Financial Plan

Realize that when you start spending more money, it becomes much easier to spend even more. For this reason, before you begin your journey from frugal to fancy, please make sure you have sat down with your loved ones and made your life plan.

From your life plan, your annual savings goals and other financial plans will naturally flow. If you haven’t done this yet, then you don’t know how much is “okay” to spend. Don’t skip this important step.

If you need professional help to create your personalized financial plan, check out the list of The Physician Philosopher’s recommended financial advisors.

#2 Pay Off Your Debt

You will notice that we paid off most of our debt before expanding our lifestyle with some of these big purchases. The only debt we have left at this point is our mortgage, which we intend to pay off in 10-15 years (instead of the traditional 30).

I don’t encourage anyone to loosen the purse strings too much until your debt is paid off. Otherwise, you’ll likely cause unnecessary financial stress (and worsening burnout when you feel trapped in a lifestyle). The best way to enjoy spending more money is to do it guilt-free.

#3 Achieve Your Annual Goals First!

You should not be spending money that you aren’t sure you “have”. In order to avoid this problem, you need to make sure your annual goals are accomplished first.

For my family, this means automating/achieving the following annual financial goals:

Going forward, any additional money that we have coming in will likely be split into various things like a travel/vacation fund, paying off the mortgage sooner, and charitable giving. Or, we can spend it lavishly on whatever else we want guilt-free!

#4 Spend the Money Wisely

Remember, that there are studies on how to spend money in a way that provides the most long-term sustained happiness or satisfaction.

The take-home when it comes to making sure you are getting the best bang for your buck is to do the following.

  1. Spend money on experiences over things.
  2. Give the money to other people or charities.
  3. Buy smaller and more often (we screwed this one up with the peloton purchase, oops!)
  4. Delay purchases to make sure it is really what you want! Do your research, and enjoy the experience of buying “stuff” if that is the direction you go.

Take Home

It is okay to spend money. You just have to make sure you have taken care of business before you go from frugal to fancy. If you are still in the midst of paying down student loans and/or you just finished training, I encourage you to adhere to The 10% Rule for the first few years out of training.

If, however, you’ve done the hard work to get your financial house in order, then you should enjoy your money guilt-free. There’s nothing wrong with going from frugal to fancy. Just remember to achieve all of those financial goals first before spending what is left.

And when you do spend the money, spend it lavishly on the things that you love and that you know will provide you the most long-term happiness and satisfaction.

Did you have a hard time loosening the purse strings after you were making great financial progress? Are you still in the throws of financial hardship? Leave a comment below.

TPP

7 Comments

  1. Psy-FI MD

    No you are no crazy for joining the peloton cult (err club). 🙂

    As you stated above…once you’ve eliminated most of your obligations, spending on what you value makes a lot of sense. That includes a commitment device such as exercise equipment.

    We have an expensive gym membership we are trying to use more frequently. We’re trying to not make that the proverbial “clothes hanger” expenditure.

    Regards,

    Psy-FI MD

    Reply
  2. VagabondMD

    We just joined the Peloton “club” last month. I need to preserve my knee cartilage as 32 years of running 3-5 times per week is taking its toll. I first tried my hand (legs) at spinning at a local club and enjoyed it enough to want to continue. If you and your wife each spin a modest once per week, you will easily make up for the cost of going to a spinning club in a short period of time, so, in fact, the Peloton might be a frugal move after all.

    Reply
    • ThePhysicianPhilosopher

      Well, if I had known that VagabondMD had bought one, I wouldn’t have even hesitated!

      Honestly, my wife will use this thing a ton. I am hoping to use it two to three times per week. If we do that, it will be well worth the cost.

      We will see how it shakes out!

      TPP

      Reply
  3. Dr. McFrugal

    I first tried Peloton on a recent vacation to Hawaii. The resort I was staying at had a Peloton and we can use the resort’s account for free.

    At first I didn’t see what all of the hoopla was all about. But when I tried it, I realized it was a lot of fun. There’s exciting instructors, you can choose the genre of music you like, and you can see how other people (like your wife or friends) are doing for a friendly competition.

    Not sure if I’ll get it for myself, but I do see the appeal.

    Never feel bad about “non frugal” purchases. I did at first, especially since the title of my site is Dr. McFrugal (ha!) . But I’ve definitely let that negative feeling go.

    As long as you have your financial ducks in a row (which you do) and you save a good percentage of your income (50%) , then it’s all good.

    There’s absolute frugality — Not spending more than $30,000 a year for example
    Then there’s relative frugality — Not spending more than 50% of your annual after tax income a year (even if it’s spending $200,000 a year).

    Nothing wrong with relative frugality. It’s still being frugal in my book 🙂

    Reply
    • ThePhysicianPhilosopher

      I’m all about some relative frugality. I used to call it “moderate” frugality, but that just isn’t the truth. Relative is a much better way to put it. Given that we are hitting our goals, I didn’t feel bad about it at all. A year or two ago I would have had some major consumer regret.

      TPP

      Reply
  4. MK

    Think of the Peloton as an annuity: sure you hand over some cash at first, but it “pays” you for the rest of your life with health, joy, and sanity … not to mention seclusion from daily stress (at least for the duration of the ride). Some rides turn my wife and me into competitive megalomaniacs, and you can’t put a price on that!

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You might also be interested in…

Budgeting That You Won’t Hate: Backwards Budgeting

Budgeting That You Won’t Hate: Backwards Budgeting

Let’s be real. Most of us hate budgeting. I know that I do. That said, I am a big believer that unintentional plans lead to lots of people ending up broke. What if I told you that there is a way to budget that you won’t hate, and it will accomplish all of your goals automatically? Too good to be true? Read on to find out…

Tips for Moonlighting in Residency: Making Extra Cash

Tips for Moonlighting in Residency: Making Extra Cash

As a PGY-4 in my anesthesiology residency, I easily doubled my salary by moonlighting in residency. Many opportunities exist for moonlighting, and the pay usually ranges from $60/hour to $150/hour depending on the nature of the call.  Today, let's hammer out the...

Time is money, but money can’t buy time

Time is money, but money can’t buy time

Please, tell me I am not the only one who thinks like this?  My monetary mindset currently revolves around our biggest (current) financial goal: Paying off our student loans. I hope that some day I can truly learn that Time is Money and that money is a means to an end. It’s not an end in itself.

Are you ready to live a life you love?