Should I go to medical school?

It is a question I get all of the time, “Would you go into medicine again if you could do it all over?” Sometimes they ask, “Would you tell your son or daughter to go into medicine?”  Today we are going to look strictly at the financial aspect of choosing whether to go to medical school (or not).

The cost of medical education

While any high-income earner can build wealth if they go about it the right way, not every physician obtains this.  In fact, many do not.  It is a common assumption that doctors are “rich,” but those making these assumptions often do not know the whole story.  We start with what feels like insurmountable debt:

The median cost of a private medical education is more than $314,000.

When I finished training, the interest rate for graduate student loans was 6.8%.  Let me say that $300,000 accumulating at 6.8% interest can be devastating, particularly if one has chosen a lesser earning field in medicine (family medicine, pediatrics, general internist, etc).

A recent study published in the AMC journal of Academic Medicine looked into both the cost of medical school when paid for by a variety of pathways (Public Service Loan Forgiveness, Military scholarships, self-paid, federally guaranteed loans, etc) and also into four different fields of medicine with a range of income that may be achieved by becoming a physician.

The four fields that they chose were general internal medicine (assumed income ~$175,000),  Opthalmology (~$215,000), general surgery (~$300,000), and orthopedic surgery (~$409,000).

Through this study, utilizing what is called Net Present Value (NPV) analysis, they determined at what point people who took on $180,000 in loans started to catch up to (and pass) students who took on a national service scholarship.  For those that entered a high paying specialty($300-400,000), this took between 4 and 11 years.  For those that entered into primary care…it never happened.  You read that right.

This is where the question of “Should I go to medical school” becomes difficult to answer financially.  It really does depend on how much debt you have and what specialty you are able to (or decide to) go into.  Choosing a specialty is somewhat self-determined if you are a competitive applicant; other less competitive applicants who are limited by USMLE scores, poor letters, or poor academic performance in medical school do not necessarily have a variety of choices to choose from.

Does it make more sense to go into another field?

Utilizing the similar NPV method mentioned above, another study (or actually, a commentary) published in the same journal looked into whether people would be better off going into an alternative field rather than going into medicine.

From that study comes the following table comparing two different careers:

First some assumptions from the graph above:

  1. The salary of the alternative field is shown in the second column (Starting at $80,000).  This number can obviously vary depending on the alternative job.
  2. This chart shows a student taking on the typical debt of medical school (~$190,000) as a negative value shown in parenthesis in column 3.  This is then followed by three years of residency and what looks like a salary on par with most internal medicine physicians.
  3. The student loan accumulation at end of medical school in the example above is a little more than $190,000
  4. In the student loan column, it appears that the resident was paying back around $26,000 in student loans during their 3 year residency, which is not typical.

With those given assumptions, the person who chooses the medical profession route would end up being up $785,000 compared to the “alternative” profession.  Are these assumptions good though?  Not really.  Very few people pay back debt during residency if we are honest.  Additionally, most of us, refinance our loans after finishing training.  The example above does not follow the typical example.

However, it still gives you an idea of whether it is “worth it” financially.  Moreover, if you choose an even higher paying specialty (ortho, anesthesia, surgery, etc) AND you refinance, then there will be an even more impressive difference in choosing a non-medical life and the life of a high-earning physician.

What does this mean?

This means that if you can find a non-medical job providing more than the income listed above or if you are going to choose a low-earning medical specialty (pediatrics, family medicine, etc), it may not make financial sense to become a physician. However, if you have a way to minimize your debt (self-paid, family paid, scholarship, military) or you are going into a high-earning specialty (>$250,000) then the decision to pursue medicine makes plenty of financial sense.

There are, of course, many other parts to this decision: potentially delaying your life while in medical school (some call this “giving up 10 years of your life,” though I didn’t feel that way), the psychosocial aspect of going into medicine (the honor of being a physician coupled with the responsibility that entails) , the presumption by everyone that you are loaded when you are really paying off boat loads of debt. Financially, though, the above line of reasoning probably holds.

What do you think?  Is going into medicine a financially wise decision?  Or would you recommend someone choose a different path?

TPP

2 thoughts on “Should I go to medical school?

  1. This isn’t the most accurate. Many Family Medicine jobs start with a $200-220 gaurantee and can easily surpass that once established. That being said it’s not wise to go into medicine for the money. That will just lead to disappointment.

    • I agree that the numbers given in that study are not exactly accurate for each speciality but liked the fact that it gave a range of incomes. While family medicine may not be accurate the lowest income they gave is substantially more than a pediatrician makes.

      Money should not be the sole determining factor about choosing to go into medicine, but thinking about this before it’s too late is the point of this post. I have colleagues that have 400,000 in debt because they chose to go a private medical education route instead of going to state school and regret it deeply.

      That isn’t the case for everyone, obviously. This provides good food for fodder.

Leave a Comment