Money Meets Medicine Podcast
The Diminishing Return of Working More
Note: Looking for a comprehensive financial platform that is created for doctors, by doctors? Make sure to join the Attend waitlist! Launching in the summer of 2023!
It often pays to work smarter, not harder, yet many doctors put in more and more hours to make more money in medicine. But is working more always a good idea?
I think there are pros and cons to working more shifts in medicine. Personal finance is personal, and you have to assess whether you feel you’re being compensated fairly for the time and energy you put into your work. Yes, you have expenses to cover, but remember the importance of work life balance, especially as it pertains to physician burnout.
Whether you work more or not, the choice should be yours
Lisha hasn’t quite felt the diminishing returns of working extra shifts just yet. But before she went to medical school, she was a policy intern at a think tank in Washington DC. It was a nonprofit that didn’t pay particularly well, especially for people like her who were fresh out of college.
She wasn’t making a lot of money, and she quickly realized that to keep food on the table and money in the bank, she would need to work more. She ended up getting a second job at a gym that was open after-hours and between that and the long commutes quickly became exhausted.
But this lesson came in handy when she entered fellowship and had the choice to take on after-hours urgent care work in sports medicine. She thought about her actual take-home pay post-tax, the time and gas spent to get to and from the clinic, the time spent de-stressing after treating 10 patients in 2 hours and decided the pay offered didn’t cover those costs.
I used to moonlight in residency, and we had an opportunity that we jokingly called “sleeping for dollars.” The hospital had to have an in-house physician to take care of overnight emergencies for post-surgical patients. But since this was in a lower acuity, outpatient hospital setup, you were almost never needed.
When I became an attending physician, picking up an extra shift was pretty decent money. I’ve mentioned several times before that in earlier life, my wife and I had just over $200,000 in loans.
Our goal from the get-go was to eliminate all of our monthly payments so that our required monthly standard of living used as few funds as possible. Getting rid of our debt was hugely important to us. It was worth it to me to take on extra shifts, earn a bunch of extra money and ultimately pay off that $200,000 in 19 months.
The role of emotional return on investment in physician burnout
Now, the extra shifts I was picking up were historically not the most popular shifts, but because they were harder work, you got paid more to do them.
As time went on, I noticed an interesting shift happening in my workplace. In those first two years, picking up extra work was somewhat elective. I could choose to do it or not. Then we got short-staffed because our needs for anesthesia grew, but our footprint didn’t grow correspondingly with it. Suddenly I was working more than I wanted to, and not by choice.
I started missing my kids’ sporting events and recitals, essentially leaving my wife to deal with everything as a single mom. The longer it went on, extra shifts weren’t worth it anymore.
You have to consider the emotional return on investment just as much as the financial return on investment.
If you’re getting paid in either of those arenas, you’ll typically feel like the reward is worth the effort. But if the emotional return on investment starts to sag, then that financial return on investment doesn’t even matter.
Understand your responsibility in creating work life balance
You have to know your role in creating your own work life balance. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve spoken with doctors who’ve told me, “My family went on vacation to the beach last week, but I didn’t go.”
When I ask why that is, they say, “Because I was paying for the vacation. Every day that I would have missed a shift, I was losing $2,000. And so a $5,000 vacation plus the $10,000 I would miss for those five days of work creates a $15,000 vacation instead of a $5,000 vacation.”
Essentially, they’ve wrapped their mindset so far around the idea of shift work and working more to make more that they haven’t taken vacation in several years.
Yet I’ve coached so many physicians who say, “I think I’d be happier working four days a week,” but for one reason or another haven’t taken steps to see if that’s a viable option.
Not every job can allow you to have a flexible work schedule and go part-time, but I think a lot of people are surprised by the fact that it’s an option if they’d ask.
If you can adjust your financial goals and lifestyle to accommodate for slightly less pay, and it not feel like a huge adjustment, then you could have more of the time that you’re looking for.
And it’s not just the time itself, but what you do with that time – irreplaceable experiences, being there for your kids while they’re still kids, enjoying your spouse and your family, traveling, creating memories – that makes the greatest impact.
Physician burnout doesn’t have a black and white solution
Is there always a diminishing return on working more? It’s not a black and white answer. Personal finance is personal, and so are the phases of life we find ourselves in at one point or another.
Maybe early in your life, you actually want to do shift work because you’re focused on paying down your student loan debt, or you’re focused on saving for a house and you’ve got multiple needs for cash and the capacity to work more.
But maybe when you’re older, you’re rid of some of those debts, and you have a family you want to see and other interests you want to pursue, all of a sudden working more to earn more doesn’t look as good.
It’s something you have to evaluate often, particularly with physician burnout being such a risk factor.
Consider additional tax cuts and how you value your time
One piece piece that could help you realize whether working more is the answer for you
is the diminishing return based on taxes. There’s a breakpoint with adjusted gross income where the federal tax rate goes from 26% to 32%.
For me personally, it very quickly becomes a moot point when I have a 32% marginal tax rate and a 5 or 6% state tax rate, meaning any additional work that I do is marginal income, and that marginal income will be taxed around 35%.
For every $100 I make, I get to keep $65. That’s a diminishing return, and it’s not really worth it for me.
Vicki Robin, author of Your Money or Your Life, encourages readers to break down your workload, the hours it takes to complete, and the amount of money you make, to determine what an hour of your life is worth.
In anesthesia, an hour of work is worth $115. So when I decide not to work and coach my kid’s soccer practice, I’m saying it’s worth $115 for me, because I could theoretically work another hour and make $115 post-tax.
Thinking about time and money through this lens helps you to spend and earn money in an intentional way.
Consider whether work life balance could exist outside medicine
There’s a reason why there’s a movement of doctors looking to earn “passive income.” Of course, no income is 100% passive. My latest book, for instance, took several months and hundreds of hours to write. But now that my part is done and it’s out in the world, I get a check every month without having to do additional work.
The same is true of any passive income, real estate avenues included. You have to do your due diligence upfront and learn how to do that, but it can pay off in the end.
If you’re a doctor that’s telling yourself, ”I have a limited skillset. I can’t do anything outside of medicine,” it’s just not true. I can’t tell you the number of physicians that branch out and wish they’d pivoted sooner.
There are ways to make money that don’t require you to work more. Maybe you love the amount of work that you have right now, but if you’re finding yourself burning out, wanting to work less, or not having that work life balance that you’re looking for, consider these options and do some reflective work to think about how you can get to where you want to be.
Subscribe and Share
If you love the show – and want to provide a 5-star review – please go to your podcast player of choice and subscribe, share, and leave a review to help other listeners find The Physician Philosopher Podcast, too!
You might also be interested in…
Are Bonds a Good Investment for Doctors?
Did you know that as interest rates rise, the value of bonds falls? Should you even care about that? Are bonds a good investment for doctors? In this episode, we’re tackling these questions and discussing the purpose of bonds in a doctor’s portfolio, as well as the nuance of our current high interest environment
Pre-tax vs Roth Investments: Which Is Right For You?
Maybe you’re starting your intern year and you’re considering investing as one of your steps in that journey. As July approaches, maybe you’re transitioning as a trainee from an institution or to a new job, you might be asking yourself, “Should I be investing in pre-tax vs Roth?”
It’s a really interesting topic and an important question, especially as interest rates and inflation changes.
Money Mistakes We Made In 2022
With inflation and interest rates being what they are, one of the most common questions that we get nowadays is, “Should I invest or pay off debt? What should I be doing with my money?”